3 Guys and a Flick - Movie Reviews

Podcast 245: Identity

This week the 3 Guys head straight into the storm with the movie Identity, a twisty 2003 thriller from James Mangold that still messes with your head.

We break down the stacked cast — John Cusack, Ray Liotta, and Amanda Peet — and dig into the creative choices that make this motel nightmare tick. From hidden clues and repeating motifs to fractured psyches, nothing escapes the Guys’ scrutiny.

We unpack the infamous twist, debate whether it still lands on repeat viewings, and cover soundtrack notes, behind-the-scenes trivia, character rankings, ratings, and a final verdict that may divide the table.

If you love psychological thrillers, big swings, and heated takes — this episode is absolutely you. 

Podcast 244: The Replacements

Suit up and hit the gridiron with the 3 Guys as we call an audible on The Replacements. 🏈 This week, the crew breaks down the ultimate underdog football flick—diving into clutch performances from Keanu Reeves and Gene Hackman, killer needle-drops, and trivia that moves the chains. We huddle up to talk strike-era inspiration, sports-movie clichés, rom-com play calls, and whether the X’s and O’s actually hold up on replay.

From the legendary bar-bonding drive to the final comeback march downfield, we celebrate the film’s heart while flagging the fumbles—pacing penalties, continuity calls, and all. Then it’s fourth-quarter banter, final ratings, and a victory formation you don’t want to miss.

If you love football movies, locker-room laughs and spirited debate, this episode is a must-listen. No scabs—just solid takes. Press play and join the huddle.

Podcast 243: 2025 Year In Review

Before we slam the door on 2025, 3 Guys and a Flick hits rewind. Fifty episodes. Countless arguments. Big wins, painful misses, and moments so ridiculous they probably shouldn’t have made the final cut—but did anyway.

We’re breaking down the stats, rankings, surprises, and full behind-the-scenes chaos that defined our year at the mic. No polish. No mercy. Just a loud, honest, and hilarious look back at everything we watched.

Thank you for riding with us all year—keep sending in those movie picks. You keep listening, we’ll keep recording. 🎙️🍿

Podcast 242: National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation

Plug in the lights, grab the eggnog, and brace yourself for a full Griswold-level meltdown.

To end our holiday movie run 3 Guys and a Flick decks the halls with a deep dive into National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation. We break down the cast, iconic scenes, and behind-the-scenes trivia that turned Clark Griswold’s perfect family Christmas into one of the most quoted holiday movies of all time.

From the legendary light display to the unforgettable Cousin Eddie payoff, we debate Chevy Chase’s endlessly optimistic (and endlessly unhinged) Clark, share our favorite moments, and wrestle with the big question: does this movie still hold up as a holiday staple — or is it more of a seasonal endurance test?

Expect personal takes, final ratings, and plenty of laughs as we go full Griswold in our latest festive review.

Podcast 241: Daddy’s Home 2

Our Holiday Series rolls on as 3 Guys and a Flick unwraps Daddy’s Home 2, the loud, ridiculous, and surprisingly warm Christmas sequel that reunites Will Ferrell and Mark Wahlberg for a “Together Christmas” that never had a chance.

This time, the festivities go completely off the rails when two grandpas crash the party — Mel Gibson’s ultra-macho wildcard and John Lithgow’s soft-spoken sweetheart — turning peace, love, and goodwill into competitive dad energy cranked to eleven. Add in John Cena, over-the-top set pieces, and nonstop holiday absurdity, and you’ve got a recipe for festive mayhem.

We break down the biggest laughs, the best running gags, the cast chemistry, and whether this sequel earns its spot on the holiday watchlist. Expect spoilers, sarcasm, belly laughs, and just enough Christmas heart to keep the lights twinkling. 🎅🎁

Plug in the lights, grab the eggnog, and join us for this holiday dad showdown.

Podcast 240: Krampus

This holiday season… not every creature coming down the chimney brings good cheer.

On this week’s episode of 3 Guys and a Flick, we’re unwrapping Krampus (2015)—a wicked winter tale where a broken family loses their Christmas spirit… and gains the attention of something far older, far colder, and far less forgiving.

Join us as we dive into the sharp-toothed stocking stuffers of this movie: the killer toys, the demonic décor, the snow-drenched dread, and the creature effects that bring the ancient Yuletide punisher to life. We’ll break down the casting, the blend of dark humor and genuine chills, and of course… that unsettling snow-globe twist that turns the whole holiday on its head.

So stoke the fire, lock the doors, and whisper your wishes carefully—because in this episode, the only thing watching you isn’t Santa… it’s Krampus.

Podcast 239: It's a Wonderful Life

This week, we ring in the holiday season by diving into one of the most beloved classics of all time: Frank Capra’s It’s a Wonderful Life. In this candid, spoiler-filled review, the guys explore the film that taught generations just how much one life can mean.

Join us as we walk the snowy streets of Bedford Falls, unpacking James Stewart’s unforgettable performance, the film’s surprising production history, and the scenes that have stayed with audiences for nearly 80 years. We follow George Bailey’s lifelong sacrifices, Clarence’s last-chance mission to earn his wings, and the haunting glimpse of Pottersville—an alternate reality where George never existed.

From heart-tugging moments to behind-the-scenes trivia, the episode builds to the emotional finale as the townspeople band together to save George in one of cinema’s most iconic endings.

Grab your holiday spirit (and maybe a tissue), because no man is a failure who has a podcast reviewing It’s a Wonderful Life.

Podcast 238: I Am Legend

This week on Three Guys and a Flick… we’re giving thanks, fighting Darkseekers, and emotionally supporting anyone still traumatized by that dog scene.

That’s right — we’re reviewing I Am Legend, the movie that proved Will Smith can carry an entire film… and also that New York City is somehow even scarier without traffic.

Join us as we break down everything: Will Smith’s powerhouse performance, the science-y apocalypse setup, the Darkseekers and their questionable skincare routines, New York as a moody supporting character, AND the battle of the century — the theatrical ending vs. the alternate ending (only one will survive).

We’re diving into casting trivia, wild production notes, and of course serving up our final ratings along with some amazing listener interactions and fresh movie-helmet submissions.

🦃 And because this episode drops on Thanksgiving, we want to say we are MOST thankful for you — our listeners. You keep us recording, debating, joking, and occasionally crying over fictional dogs.

Podcast 237: Rudy

🏈 Suit up and hit the tunnel — The Three Guys and a Flick are tackling Rudy!

Don, Ken, and Jon break down Sean Astin’s heartfelt performance, the key players who help drive the story downfield, and Jerry Goldsmith’s score that hits like a perfect spiral pass.

They run through the film’s most inspiring moments, the Fortune scenes fans still cheer for, the final game that delivers the ultimate goosebumps, and wrap it all up with their rating.

If you love underdog stories, gridiron grit, and classic sports cinema, this is an episode you don’t want to miss. RUDY RUDY RUDY!

Podcast 236: La La Land

Get ready to dance through dreams and heartbreak with 3 Guys and a Flick as we step into the dazzling world of La La Land! 

From its jaw-dropping opening number on the freeway to that unforgettable ending, we break down Damien Chazelle’s modern musical masterpiece — diving into the chemistry between Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling, the film’s bittersweet take on love and ambition, and the magic of chasing your dreams even when reality hits hard.

Expect trivia, behind-the-scenes stories, and a few unexpected laughs as we debate whether La La Land deserved all those Oscars, if Sebastian and Mia were meant to be, and why this film still hits you right in the feels.